1991 New York Giants - Buffalo Bills 20:19 (Tampa, Florida)

1992 Washington Redskins - Buffalo Bills 37:24 (Minneapolis, Minnesota)

1993 Dallas Cowboys - Buffalo Bills 52:17 (Pasadena, Kalifornien)

1994 Dallas Cowboys - Buffalo Bills 30:13 (Atlanta, Georgia)

1995 San Francisco 49ers - San Diego Chargers 49:26 (Miami, Florida)

1996 Dallas Cowboys - Pittsburgh Steelers 27:17 (Tempe, Arizona)

1997 Green Bay Packers - New England Patriots 35:21 (New Orleans,Louisiana)

1998 Denver Broncos - Green Bay Packers 31:24 (San Diego, Kalifornien)

1999 Denver Broncos - Atlanta Falcons 34:19 (Miami, Florida)

2000 St. Louis Rams - Tennessee Titans 23:16 (Atlanta, Georgia)

2001 Baltimore Ravens - New York Giants 34:7 (Tampa, Florida)

2002 New England Patriots - St. Louis Rams 20:17 (New Orleans, Louisiana)

2003 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Oakland Raiders 48:21 (San Diego, Kalifornien)

2004 New England Patriots - Carolina Panthers 32:29 (Houston, Texas)

2005 New England Patriots - Philadelphia Eagles 24:21 (Jacksonville, Fl.)

2006 Pittsburgh Steelers - Seattle Seahawks 21:10 (Detroit, Michigan)

2007 Indianapolis Colts - Chicago Bears 29:17 (Miami Gardens, Florida)

2008 New York Giants - New England Patriots 17:14 (Glendale, Arizona)

2009 Pittsburgh Steelers - Arizona Cardinals 27:23 (Tampa, Florida)

2010 New Orleans Saints - Indianapolis Colts 31:17 (Miami, Florida)

2011 Green Bay Packers - Pittsburgh Steelers 31:25 (Arlington, Texas)